Flooby.com
Home
Flooby Reviews
FC vs. the LSH
TJ's Web Log
Mike's Web Log
About Flooby.com
Links
E-Mail
Flooby Carrot!

COMICS I’M
CURRENTLY READING

A Distant Soil •  Action Comics • Adventures Of Superman • Age of Bronze • Alias • Amy Unbounded • Astro City •  Batgirl • Berlin • Birds Of Prey • Bone • Boneyard • Buffy The Vampire Slayer • Catwoman • Colonia • Daredevil • Demo • Dork • Electric Girl • Fables • Fade from Blue • Finder • Futurama Comics • Gotham Central • Green Arrow • Green Lantern • Growing Up Enchanted • Hawkman • Hellboy • JLA • JSA • Jane's World • Last Kiss • Legion of Super-Heroes • Lucifer • Madman Comics  • Nightwing • Nyx • Private Beach • Promethea • Queen & Country • Savage Dragon • Shades of Blue •  Sidekicks • Strangers in Paradise • Stray Bullets • Superman  • Superman The Man Of Steel • Tom Strong • Terra Obscura (mini) • Ultimate X-Men • Y-The Last Man

New Flooby Reviews

My Faith in Frankie #1-4 (of 4)

Writer: Mike Carey
Penciler: Sonny Liew
Inker: Sonny Liew & Marc Hempel
Colors: Hi-Fi Design
Letters: John Costanza
Assistant Editor: Mariah Huehner
Editor: Shelly Bond
Publisher: Vertigo/DC Comics $2.95 US $4.50 CAN
Click Here for a Sample Page

My Faith in Frankie #1Frankie is an all American teen. She’s cute, smart and she also has her own personal diety. Jeriven (God of the Heart’s Fires) “met” Frankie when she was just a baby and he was a very young god. He needed worshippers and Frankie was perfect.

Perfect, that is, until she hit puberty. When Frankie’s hormones went into action so did Jeriven. He sabotaged every date Frankie had and she was sick of it. Frankie’s best friend, Kay is the only other person who knows about Jeriven but she’s never really believed he really existed. She just thought Frankie was incredibly lucky and well, perfect. Enter Frankie’s childhood friend, Dean. He’s all grown up, cute and interested in Frankie. Finally she’ll be able to see what all the fuss is about. What Frankie doesn’t know is that Dean has an agenda and it includes Jeriven.

I picked this mini-series up because it didn’t sound like your usual downer Vertigo mini. It actually sounded fun. Luckily the story was quirky and cute and the art complimented the tone perfectly.

Things kind of took a jarring turn in the final issue when the writer decided to mess with the light-hearted tone by getting all dark and throwing the ‘f’ word around a lot. I’m not put off by harsh language but it seemed out of place and forced.
The artwork by Liew and Hempel worked well. Marc Hempel is an old hand at comics and his covers for this mini were eye-catching. Sonny Liew’s pencils might have been a little over-powered by Hempel’s inks. I looked at Sonny Liew’s site (www.sonnyliew.com) and I loved the samples of his penciled work. The artwork in
My Faith in Frankie wasn’t as lush and detailed.

Overall, My Faith in Frankie was a decent read. You won’t get deep thoughts and earth-shattering revelations from this comics, just good clean fun about a girl and her god.

You should be able to find this comic at your local shop. You can visit the Vertigo Comics web site at www.dccomics.com/vertigo/.

A little picture to divide the reviews.

Halloween-Man: It Came from Texas

Writer: Drew Edwards
Penciler: Various
Inker: Various
Colors: B&W
Letters: Various
Publisher: Self-published digest $3.00 US
Click Here for a Sample Page

Halloween-Man: It Came from TexasSolomon Hitch is your average down-on-your luck wannabe writer with a rich girlfriend. One night he’s attacked by a vampire and killed. Lucky for Solomon a wizard who goes by the name Morlack is drawn to “the one most wronged by the supernatural” and offs the vampire. Unfortunately he’s too late to save Solomon. Enter wacky wizard powers and he brings Solomon back to life as a zombie. A zombie whose job it will be to protect Solar City from supernatural evil.
Solar City is an interesting place. Not only do they have the aptly named Halloween-Man fighting crime but Solomon’s best friend is a super-hero known as Man-Goat. There’s also a legit super-hero group know as The Sentinels but they don’t sully their fists with the bad guys Halloween-Man battles.

The stories in this collection are illustrated by various artists but my favorite stories were those by Terry Parr. The original art for this collection is larger and in color so at times I had trouble making out the action in some of the darker panels. Also the size reduction made it hard to read a few word balloons.

The stories are light-hearted and a little tongue-in-cheek. Edwards loves horror movies and pays homage to them throughout so that was fun. I liked the fact that before each story in this collection he writes a brief explanation of where he got the idea for the story. Halloween-Man’s world is chock full of weird stuff, which shouldn’t be too surprising when your hero is a zombie.

I really liked the fact that Solomon’s girlfriend Lucy wasn’t always ending up in danger and having to be rescued. She’s a strong character in her own right and with an amazing intellect and the ability to invent rayguns, jetpacks and flying cars.
I did find myself wishing the stories had contained a little more background on a few of the minor characters. Nicko, a character introduced in “Man-Goat’s Gruff: Part 1,” gives Solomon an enchanted shovel but I had no idea where this guy came from.

If you like your super-hero comics on the quirky side, give Halloween-Man a shot.

You probably won’t find this title at your local comic shop but you can order it online at www.halloweenman.com. This digest-sized ashcan edition comes in a full-sized color version.

Past Flooby Reviews

 

Kickass Girl #1

Writer: Billy Martinez
Penciler: Billy Martinez
Inker: Billy Martinez
Colors: B&W
Letters: Krystal Clausen
Editor: Angi Martinez
Publisher: Neko Press $2.99 US
Click Here for a Sample Page

Kickass Girl #1Okay. I admit it. I bought this comic because of the title. After all, how could I resist a comic called Kickass Girl?

Katrina has had a hard life. Her mom killed herself, her dad verbally and physically abuses her and she goes to school with some real assholes. Sounds like it could turn into a nice slice of life drama about a troubled teen, right? Nope. After Katrina gives her dad a butt kicking she is visited by an archangel named Michelle and told that she has been given a special power and "a higher purpose" in life. Michelle shows Katrina her future and sends her to California to wait for her return.

As a first issue, Kickass Girl wasn't bad. It wasn't great but it wasn't bad. It introduced you to Katrina, the main character and set up the premise for future issues quite ably. And it also brought up some questions that hopefully will be answered as the series progresses. Questions like why did Michelle send Katrina to California? What happened to Katrina's dad? How old is Katrina exactly? I'm guessing she's in high school but the art style makes it difficult to figure out. And finally, who the heck is the skeleton dude who shows up at the end of the comic?

The artwork in Kickass Girl reminded me of what you might get if Margaret Keane had been a manga artist. Not all of the characters have big eyes, however. Some of them get those creepy all white Little Orphan Annie eyes. I did find myself wishing that some of the panels hadn't been quite so large but I know that's just my old-fashioned love of having a lot of story crammed into an issue rearing its ugly head.

Kickass Girl is a black and white comic but the shading was done digitally. Not my favorite way to do a black and white comic. I'd rather see just plain black and white line art than computer applied gray tones. I know it's probably done that way to give the book a color feel but it tends to detract from the art.

Overall, this was an average first issue. If you like comics with girls who kick butt, give this title a try.

If you can't find this comic locally, write to Neko Press, P.O. Box 1454, La Mesa, CA 91944-1454. You can also visit their web site at www.nekopresscomics.com.

A little picture to divide the reviews.

Fray #1–8 (of 8)

Writer: Joss Whedon
Penciler: Karl Moline
Inker: Andy Owens
Colors: Dave Stewart & Michelle Madsen (8)
Letters: Michelle Madsen
Editor: Scott Allie
Assistant Editor: Michael Carriglitto & Matt Dryer (7, 8)
Publisher: Dark Horse Comics $2.99 US $4.50
Click Here for a Sample Page

Fray #1When Fray #1 came out, I read it immediately. Then I decided that I'd wait for the entire mini-series to be completed before I read the rest. Who knew I'd be waiting for two years for that to happen. Not that I can really fault Joss Whedon. I know the man was working on Buffy, Angel, and Firefly while he was working on this comic. Not to mention being introduced to the joys of fatherhood. The guy had a lot on his plate. But I am happy to report that even with the two years it took to complete this eight issue mini-series the final product was worth the wait.

Fray is about Melaka Fray, a young woman from the 26th century surviving in a hard city by being a grabber, which means she steals things. But she's no common, mug-you-on-the-street thief, she's a thief for hire and a darn good one. Her speed, strength and reflexes make her unusually successful at what she does.

Mel lives a fairly solitary existence until a demon named Urkonn arrives to tell her of her destiny as a vampire slayer—although here they're known as lurkers or lurks. Mel doesn't believe him. Lurks are just another mutation in a world filled with mutations. Urkonn, who has a classic demon look to him, doesn't even phase Mel. But it turns out Mel is indeed the Slayer and she's needed to stop demon kind from being unleashed on her world.

I don't want to give too much of the story away but suffice it to say Fray is full of twists and turns that keep you interested until the very end of the story. I found myself wishing it had been the first eight issues of an ongoing series or the pilot for a new television show.

Whedon's flair for dialogue shines in the comic book form. And all the practice he's gotten with television writing has given him a great sense of pacing between issues. I'm glad I didn't read these as they came out because I probably would have ended up being very frustrated thanks to the marvelous cliffhanger endings.

Karl Moline (pencils) and Andy Owens (inks) do a fantastic job with the art on this series. I love the whole world they've created for Mel to inhabit. Karl Moline's character designs are fresh and his vamps/lurks are suitably scary. No part of the art is given short shrift. The background details are just as much fun to look at as the character details. Even if, as a Fray fan site I read stated, Karl Moline was the cause for the delays his art was worth the wait.

Fray is an entertaining addition to the Buffy mythos but you don't have to be a Buffy fan to enjoy it. I'm looking forward to more comics featuring this character.

Dark Horse is putting out a hardcover and a trade edition of this series so if you missed the mini-series initially never fear. Hit up your local comic shop for a copy. Or write to Dark Horse Comics, Inc., 10956 SE Main Street, Milwaukie, OR 97222 or visit their web site at www.darkhorse.com and order it on-line.

A little picture to divide the reviews.

Blood and Water #1–5 (of 5)

Writer: Judd Winick
Penciler: Tomm Coker
Inker: Tomm Coker
Colors: Jason Wright
Letters: Kurt Hathaway
Covers: Brian Bolland
Editor: Mariah Huehner & Heidi MacDonald
Assistant Editor: Zachary Rau
Publisher: Vertigo/DC Comics $2.95 US $4.95 CAN
Click Here for a Sample Page

Blood and Water #1I know what you’re thinking. Vampires? Again?!? Let me put your fears to rest. It’s not as bad as you think. In fact, Judd Winick (Barry Ween, Boy Genius) pens an entertaining little tale about vamps and he puts his own spin on the mythos.

Adam Heller is a twenty-something man with hepatitis A which has pretty much left his body a wreck. He smells bad because of the meds he has to take to stay alive, he can’t eat most anything because he’ll just puke it up again, and he’s retaining water in his midsection giving him an odd fat look. Oh, and he just found out he’s got liver cancer and is going to die. You’d think with all that ails Adam, death would be a blessing. But Adam doesn’t want to die. He’s young and has had to live the best years of his life like an invalid old man.

Enter Joshua and Nicole, Adam’s closest friends. They are not sick but are the very picture of health and youth. They don’t rub Adam’s nose in it though and they’ve been good friends throughout his illness. It turns out, however, that Joshua and Nicole have a secret—they’re vampires. And Joshua wants to save Adam by making him a vampire. He would be cured, have everlasting life and all he would have to do is drink blood. Only animal blood though because it turns out vamps who imbibe human blood turn into rabid junkies and end up being hunted down by their saner animal blood-drinking brethren.

Of course, Adam takes them up on their offer and things get weird. I don’t want to go into just how weird because that would give the story away and I hate when reviews tell the whole freakin’ story and then you don’t have any reason to read the comic. Suffice it to say, Adam is special even among vamps and his being turned creates a whole lot of problems for vamp and humankind alike.

Winick has crafted an entertaining vamp tale and it looks like he’s left an opening for a sequel. In this mini-series we get to see Adam adjust to going from being human to vampire. A sequel could follow Adam as he learns to deal with being a vamp that gives other vamps the heebie jeebies.

The artwork by Tomm Coker in this mini was outstanding. In fact, Coker is given co-creator credits with Winick so hopefully if there is a sequel Coker will be doing the art chores. As with most Vertigo artists, Coker handles the human form superbly. He can actually illustrate backgrounds and the panels are chosen for storytelling effect not coolness factor.

If I had one complaint about this mini it would have to be that it went by far too fast. That could be a consequence of Winick doing time in the super-hero trenches (Green Lantern, Green Arrow) where fast-moving and short story arcs are the norm. I wouldn’t have minded a little more build-up/background for the final confrontation even if it stretched the series to six issues.

Blood and Water was a fun romp with the vampire mythos. Pick it up now or wait for the trade paperback collection.

You can visit the DC Comics/Vertigo web site at www.dccomics.com.

A little picture to divide the reviews.

Legacy of the Samurai #1

Writer: Nicole Lauria
Penciler: Michael Nghiem
Inker: Michael Nghiem
Colors: Jason “Crow” Barcalow
Letters: John “Beast” Boyle
Publisher: Tyred Tiger Comics $2.95 US $4.50 CAN
Click Here for a Sample Page

Legacy of the Samurai #1Legacy of the Samurai is an aptly named comic since it deals with a samurai named Dayar “on a quest to find the people responsible for the murder of his beloved sensei.” However, don’t expect a realistic feudal Japanese society. The setting is more along the lines of a fantasy feudal Japan populated with fantastic creatures and magic users. We get introduced to a couple of probable bad guys in this issue but their actions are all foreshadowing of dastardly deeds to come.

And as with any good quest, Dayar meets up with an “elementalist” named Rana Cutler who had been trying to find Dayar’s sensei to help her control her powers. A little further down the road, they then meet an adventurer named Thomas Wyler who was asked by Dayar’s sensei to help him find the killer. And finally, a freaky cat man (AxoCat) pops out of nowhere warning of something tracking them.

I know Nicole Lauria has a well-thought out plan for this series but the story in issue one suffered from too much information too soon. Introducing so many sub-plots right off the bat might seem like a good idea and a sure-fire way to hook new readers but I’m just as happy getting to know a character first and then being introduced to his/her baggage. Bringing Dayar and Rana Cutler together in issue one would have been a great starting point. Introducing the Thomas Wyler character who was also tied to Dayar’s sensei maybe an issue or two down the road would have made their meeting seem a lot less contrived. As it was, the plot seemed a bit too much like the start of a role-playing game where all of your player characters have to meet up so the action can begin.

The artwork in Legacy of the Samurai was very reminiscent of the Rob Liefeld school of comic illustration. Not really my thing but I can see where it would be a popular style for an inexperienced artist to emulate. Michael Nghiem handles backgrounds a lot better than Liefeld but there are still far too many scowling close-ups for my taste. I’d also like to see Nghiem put as much creativity into his human male characters as he did into his females who were quite well done and his beast/thug creatures are nicely designed. To Nghiem’s credit he doesn’t get carried away with the huge splash panels that eat up space in a comic but leave very little room for storytelling.

A big drawback to the artwork in this comic would have to be the coloring. I’m not sure why, but so many times computer colored comics come out way too dark. Major background details are obscured in this issue because the colors are too dark and muddy. Lighten up the palette, soften the tones and I guarantee you the book will look 100% better.

Nicole Lauria obviously has a lot planned for this title. She’s also got an enthusiastic bunch to help her fulfill those plans. Enthusiasm can take you a long way but I’d like to see this title gain a lot more polish before I could wholeheartedly recommend it.

If you’d like to give this title a try and can’t find it at your local comic shop, write Tyred Tiger Comics, 417 Burmont Road, Drexel Hill, PA 19026.

A little picture to divide the reviews.

Midnight, Mass #1–8 (of 8)

Writer: John Rozum
Penciler: Jesús Saiz
Inker: Jimmy Palmiotti
Colors: Noelle Giddings (1–3), Kevin Somers (4–8)
Letters: Ken Bruzenak (1–3), John Costanza (4–8)
Covers: Tomer Hanuka
Editor: Heidi MacDonald (1–6), Zachary Rau (7, 8)
Assistant Editor: Zachary Rau
Publisher: Vertigo/DC Comics $2.50 US $4.25 CAN
Click Here for a Sample Page

Midnight, Mass #1I intended to review this not long after the mini-series finished but never got around to it. Then I was just not going to review it because so much time had passed. But I was browsing through a current Comic Shop News (www.csnsider.com) and saw that another Midnight, Mass mini-series is on DC’s schedule for this year so I figured what the heck.

Midnight, Mass gets it name from the town in which the story’s main characters live. Midnight, Massachusetts is about 30 miles outside of Boston and, from the outside anyway; it looks like any other sleepy New England town. But once the sun sets weird things can happen in Midnight. So it’s either lucky or incredibly unlucky that the town’s two most famous residents, Adam and Julia Kadmon are paranormal investigators. Adam Kadmon comes from a long line of paranormal investigators so he ends up being the brains of the team. Need an obscure incantation to trap a demon running amok, Adam’s your man. Need enough firepower to stop that same demon, then Julia’s the one for the job. They’re the perfect team. Add to this mix the Kadmon’s new assistant, Jenny Swan. Jenny is new to the supernatural biz but she’s got a logical mind and a résumé packed with programming and computer skills.

My first impression on reading this mini-series was that it read a lot like an ongoing series because there’s no overall story arc for the eight issues. For example, issues 1–3 introduce the characters and follow Adam and Julia while they investigate reports of monsters living in an old farmhouse in Derry, New Hampshire.

Issues 4–6 introduce a new story arc and a rival collector of supernatural artifacts, Harmon O’Neill. Harmon hires Adam and Julia because someone is after an urn that once held one of the four sisters. The myth says that one of the four sisters became evil and wreaked havoc and killed thousands in India. The other three sisters stopped her, had all of their bodies cremated and put in an urn so that if the evil one were ever resurrected the other three sisters could be summoned and help destroy the fourth sister again. All is not as it seems with the four sisters or Harmon O‘Neill, however, and the Kadmons are led on a chase complete with cults, human sacrifice and demon possession.

Finally issues 7 and 8 show a bit more about Jenny Swan and we discover that she graduated from M.I.T. and had her heart broken by her college sweetheart. But, running away from the real world to nurse a broken heart turns out not to be the only reason for Jenny’s desire to work for the Kadmons and it takes the help of an archangel to solve the problem.

I really enjoyed this mini-series and my first impression that it read like an ongoing series was on the mark as I discovered while reading the aforementioned CSN. Midnight, Mass had originally been on the schedule as a new ongoing series but the powers-that-be at DC decided to cut it back to a mini which was incredibly short-sighted.

John Rozum’s writing on this series is crisp, well paced and imaginative. His characters act and talk like real people. There’s no goofy paranormal posturing unless the story calls for the villain to be a little over-the-top (Harmon O’Neill). The banter between Julia and Adam is wonderful in that you get to see a married couple who obviously love each other but aren’t above getting a bit snippy now and then—just like real married people, gasp!

The art by Jesús Saiz and Jimmy Palmiotti is perfectly suited to the mood of the comic and the supernatural characters are illustrated just as ably as the more human ones. Facial expressions are a particular strong suit for Jesús Saiz and his realistic style just adds to the smooth flow of the story.

Probably the only thing I wasn’t too crazy about were the covers for this series. Tomer Hanuka did all the covers and while they capture the supernatural feel of the series I don’t think they really made the issues stand out from the crowd. I would have liked to see what Saiz and Palmiotti could have come up with in the cover department.

Midnight Mass was a fun and entertaining series and if Vertigo had kept in as an ongoing series I’d be right there at the comic store every month plunking down my $2.50. Do yourself a favor and when the second Midnight, Mass mini comes out, pick it up and see for yourself.

You might be able to find these issues in your local comic shop still and if DC hasn’t collected a trade of these issues I bet they’ll release one before the next mini comes out. You could go to the DC Comics/Vertigo web site (www.dccomics.com) for more information but they probably won’t have anything on Midnight, Mass until the second mini-series is put on the schedule.

A little picture to divide the reviews.

Jane’s World #1–3

Writer: Paige Braddock
Penciler: Paige Braddock
Inker: Paige Braddock
Colors: B&W
Letters: I'm guessing Paige Braddock
Publisher: Girl Twirl Comics $2.95 US
Click Here for a Sample Page

Jane's World #2Jane is just your average gal. She’s employed at a San Francisco newspaper, she’s got a roommate (Evan), a girlfriend (Sarah) and an above average imagination.

Jane’s World started life as a comic strip. In fact, you can visit www.janesworldcomics.com and see all of them to date and subscribe to the new ones. Paige Braddock wanted a way to collect her strips and opted for the comic book format. If you’re like me you’ll have some trepidation about picking up this title because of this. Strip collections in comic form almost never work. I’d rather just have the strips collected in a nice fat trade because then I feel I’m getting something substantial. To her credit, Paige Braddock has tried to make the Jane’s World strips flow like a comic and, for the most part, she succeeds.

In issue one we meet Jane and her cast of characters, including her new mysterious nemesis, Chelle. This issue reads entirely too much like a collection of strips and ends up being choppy as a result. The banter between characters is typical pared down comic strip-speak and the issue never really clicks as a comic.

Issue two finds Jane, Sarah, Jane’s sister Becca and Chelle heading out for an afternoon of sailing on the San Francisco Bay. Jane isn’t what you’d call an experienced sailor (actually none of them are) and when the boat is caught in a freak squall Jane is knocked unconscious and you get to see why Jane’s imagination has a life of its own. I don’t want to spoil the issue but the story involving Jane and Chelle washing up on an island populated by gorgeous Amazons was a hoot and read like an honest-to-god comic book.

The third issue sees Jane being sent to work at The Poultry Times doing “community outreach” for her paper. I got the impression she was sent out of California for the two week assignment which seems odd for a San Francisco paper but I suspended disbelief and went with it. Jane is aghast at being sent to the sticks and is soon looking for a way out of this assignment. In a twist that can only happen in the world of comics, Jane hops on a bus, ends up in Memphis, TN, meets up with her roommate Evan and they end up being abducted by hot rodding aliens. This issue fell somewhere between the previous two in terms of flowing like a comic. Paige Braddock supplies a few typewritten scene change links along with some panels that look to have been drawn to expand the story and make it flow better. Overall it works but there are still several points where the strip nature of the story comes on strong.

Even with its flaws I’ve enjoyed this series. Jane is a quirky character and the fantastical nature of her world makes this a title that shouldn’t get boring. Paige Braddock’s cartooning style is loose and fun and fits the tone of her stories perfectly. I still think she might have been better off just collecting her Jane’s World strip into a larger trade format. It certainly would have been easier on her and it probably would sell better in the long run. But if you’re looking for something that’s fun, imaginative and well-drawn, check out Jane’s World. I have a feeling that as she gets more issues under her belt the stories should flow even more smoothly.

If you can’t find this comic at your local shop, write to Jane’s World c/o Paige Braddock P.O. Box 88, Sebastopol, CA 95472. You can visit the Jane’s World web site at www.janesworldcomics.com.

A little picture to divide the reviews.

Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Tales of the Slayers

Writer: Various
Penciler: Various
Inker: Various
Colors: I don't know! The comic has been packed!
Letters: Ditto
Editor: Ditto
Publisher: Dark Horse Comics $14.95 US $22.95 CAN
Click Here for a Sample Page

BTVS: Tales of the SlayersThose of you not well versed in Buffy lore may not be aware of the fact that Buffy is just one in a long line of young women who have taken on the mantle of Vampire Slayer. Throughout the centuries when a Chosen One dies another takes her place. This collection presents the reader with a few tales of other Slayers.

That premise alone makes this a worthwhile read for any Buffy fan but in addition you get stories penned by Joss Whedon (the show’s creator) and several of the show’s writers.

Joss Whedon writes the first story, “Prologue,” which follows the prehistoric first Slayer who has also made brief appearances in the BTVS television show. The pencils are capably handled by Leinil Francis Yu (Wolverine).

Whedon also handles the second tale in the collection, “Righteous.” This story was one of my favorites and relates the sad story of a Slayer operating within a walled medieval town during a particularly superstitious time in Europe’s history. Tim Sale supplies the beautiful art for this story.

“The Innocent” takes place during the French Revolution and was written by Amber Benson the actress who portrays Tara on the television show. This isn’t her first foray into comic book writing. She also wrote a Willow & Tara one shot with Christopher Golden. She handles this story solo, however and does a wonderful job. Ted Naifeh (Gloomcookie) illustrates it.

Jane Espenson handles “Presumption” another story that ended up being a stand out in the collection. It gives us an interesting twist on how a young Slayer might operate in the English upper crust society of 1813. P. Craig Russell (Ring of Nibelung: Rhinegold), of course, does a wonderful job with the illustration chores.

The American West and a Navajo Slayer are the stars of “The Glittering World,” written by David Fury. The interesting thing about this story was Richard Wilkins the long-lived (until Season Three at least) supernaturally powered Mayor of Sunnydale makes an appearance and we see the beginnings of Sunnydale as a town. And who better to handle the realistic and harsh setting than Steve Lieber (Whiteout).

Rebecca Rand Kirshner brings us “Sonnenblume” and a young Hitler era Slayer learns who the true monsters are. Israeli illustrator, Mira Freidmann (Bittersweet) handles the art in this story and her style is incredibly creepy and the most distinctive (and least “comic book”) of the collection.

“Nikki Goes Down!” written by Doug Petrie, presents a 1970s era New York City Slayer we’ve seen before in the television show as one of Spike’s infamous Slayer kills. Gene Colan (Tomb of Dracula) handles the art and he did such a fantastic job that I’d love to see him illustrate more BTVS tales.

The final story in the collection, “Tales,” is written by Joss Whedon and shows his character Maleeka Fray discovering a former watcher’s sanctuary and records of her Slayer forebears. Karl Moline (Route 666), the regular Fray artist also illustrates this story.

Dark Horse is doing a good job of supplying Buffy fanatics with comic based stories in the Buffy universe. Some have been better than others but this collection definitely deserves to be viewed as one of the better and more entertaining efforts.

You should be able to find this on your local comic store’s shelves. If not, write to Dark Horse Comics, Inc., 10956 SE Main Street, Milwaukie, OR 97222 or visit their web site at www.darkhorse.com and order it on-line.

A little picture to divide the reviews.

Robin Hood and the Minstrel

Writer: Paul D. Storrie
Penciler: Rich Gulick
Inker: Steve Bird
Colors: Ken Wolak and Dawn Groszewski
Letters: Donna Gentile-Karas
Editor: Lori Gentile-Strons
Publisher: Moonstone $5.95 US $9.95 CAN
Click Here for a Sample Page

Robin Hood and the MinstrelRobin Hood and his band of merry men, a headstrong young wandering minstrel and thwarted love are the ingredients for a rousing fantasy tale in Robin Hood and the Minstrel. This one-shot story is entertaining and moves along at a good clip yet still provides the reader with satisfying character moments. The setting for this tale is more fantasy-technicolor than gritty-medieval but that definitely fit the light-hearted tone of the story.

The artwork by Rich Gulick and Steve Bird is outstanding. Clean layouts, distinctive character designs and an attention to detail made this a beautiful comic to read. The style reminded me a bit of what you’d get if you crossed Dave Johnson (Chain Gang War, Superpatriot) with Kevin Maguire (Justice League, Strikeback).

I also have to mention the coloring on this book by Ken Wolak and Dawn Groszewski. I’m not always the biggest fan of computer coloring but these two have crafted a computer colored comic that is the best I’ve ever seen. The textures they used on trees, fur hats and stone really enhanced the artwork rather than muddying it as I find in a lot of computer colored comics. The characters and the setting came to life due to their deft handling of tones and shading.

The weakest part of the package though is the lettering. In such a professionally produced comic, the rough lettering was a bit of a distraction and illustrates how seamlessly lettering should mesh with the book.

Overall I was impressed by this comic and not just because I’m a sucker for Robin Hood stories. The team on Robin Hood and the Minstrel has produced an entertaining and beautiful comic that should please any fan of fantasy comics.

If you can’t find this locally, write to Moonstone, 582 Torrence Avenue, Calumet City, IL 60409.

A little picture to divide the reviews.

Want to read older Flooby Reviews? Go to the Archives page.


HomeFlooby ReviewsFlooby Reviews Archives Flaming Carrot vs. the Legion of Super-HeroesTJ’s Web Log
Mike’s Web LogAbout Flooby.comFlooby Carrot!Who is the Flaming Carrot?Hodge Lodge UpdateLinks E-Mail

Flaming Carrot™ and Flaming Carrot Comics™ © 2000 Bob Burden.

Click here to join the Comic Book Reviews Net Ring!
Previous SiteList SitesRandomNext Site